"It was God's will" and other faith wounds
By Rachel · Updated 2026-07-21 · 3 min read
The short answer
Phrases like "it was God's will" and "you just need more faith" are usually said by kind people, but they can wound because they hand a grieving person a reason before they have absorbed the loss, and they ask for grief to be smaller. The hurt comes from human certainty, not from faith itself; for many grievers faith is still the thing holding them up. What helps instead is presence without explanation: praying beside someone, sitting with them, and letting the mystery stay a mystery.
The casserole dishes are still warm on the counter when someone leans across them and says it. It was God's will.
She is three days out from the funeral. And a person she loves, meaning nothing but kindness, has just handed her a reason for the worst thing that has ever happened to her.
So many of you have told me about the sentence that arrived at exactly the wrong moment. In the receiving line. Over the phone. In the comments under a photo of the person you lost.
They are almost always said by good people. That is the part that makes them so hard to hold.
The sentences that leave a mark
You have your own collection. Most grievers do.
It was God's will. You just need more faith. If you really trusted, you would not be this sad.
Grief itself reframed as a failure, mourning too long or too loud recast as ingratitude, as though loving someone out loud were a sin against the plan.
And two more, so common they have worn a groove. They are not in a better place, not to you, not yet, maybe not ever. And it is not true that everything happens for a reason, however gently the words are offered, before any reason could possibly be known.
The wound was never faith. It was the certainty.
It is the certainty, not the belief
Here is what so many of you have said, in almost the same words. It was not God that hurt me. It was the person who spoke for God.
Faith, for a lot of you, is the thing still holding the floor up. The prayer muttered in the hospital corridor. The candle that stays lit. The sense, however faint, that the story is not finished. Some of you find your faith breaks anyway, and that is its own grief.
What wounds is a different thing entirely. It is another person reaching for certainty about the unknowable, and using it to close a door you needed left open.
A faith that demands you feel less is not comfort. It is a bill arriving in the worst week of your life.
For the person who wants to say something
If you love someone who is grieving, and you share their faith, you do not have to explain the loss to help them carry it.
You can pray beside them without telling them why it happened. You can sit in the pew and say nothing at all. You can let the mystery stay a mystery, which is, after all, what faith was always asking of you.
The most faithful thing anyone said to me, one of you wrote once, was this. I don't understand it either. And I'm here.
That sentence hands over no reason. It shrinks nothing. It just stays in the room.
Questions people also ask
Why does "it was God's will" hurt so much?
Because it arrives as certainty about something no one can be certain of, and it asks the griever to accept a reason for their loss before they have even absorbed that it is real. Even from someone who shares their faith, it can land as a door closing rather than an arm around them. What helps instead is presence without explanation: here is what to say.
Is it wrong to feel angry at God after a loss?
No. Anger, doubt and the question "why" are ancient parts of almost every faith, not a betrayal of it. Grief tests belief because it takes belief seriously. Feeling furious at God is not the same as losing God, and plenty of people find their way back through the anger rather than around it.
More in Faith, meaning and signs, or browse the whole library.