Happy Grieving

When grief breaks your faith

The short answer

It is very common for a death to shake or break a person's faith. You might feel angry at God, doubt what you were taught, or find that the belief which once made loss bearable no longer holds. Your faith might deepen instead, or you might live in the honest middle, unsure. None of these is wrong, and losing both a person and a belief at once is its own particular loneliness.

The rosary is still in the drawer where you keep the important things. You have not touched it since the funeral.

For years it was the thing your hand reached for without thinking. Now it sits there, and your hand stays still.

Maybe for you it's the prayer that stops halfway. The pew you cannot sit in anymore. The candle you used to light, unlit on the sill.

When the floor gives way

Your faith might have been more than one belief among many. It was the floor, the thing everything else stood on.

You were told there was a plan. You were told they would be held, that none of it was random, that it would all mean something in the end.

And then it happened anyway. The worst thing, to the person who least deserved it, on an ordinary Tuesday.

The floor gave way. And you were standing on nothing, just when you needed something to stand on.

The anger you are not supposed to feel

You might carry an anger that frightens you: anger at God.

At a God who could have and did not. Who watched, and let it happen, and stayed silent through every prayer you sent up.

You are not supposed to say this out loud, so you don't. You add it to the pile of things grief made you feel that you cannot admit to anyone.

But the anger is not the opposite of faith. Sometimes it is the last thread of it, the part of you still addressing someone, still expecting an answer, still furious that none came.

Losing two things at once

Here is what makes this loneliness so specific.

You lost your person, and you lost the belief that used to make loss bearable. The person who would have talked you through it, and the faith that would have, both gone at once.

And often a third thing goes too. The community. The people at the service who assume you still believe, whose words land wrong now, who cannot follow you to the place their certainty never had to reach.

You lost the story that was supposed to make losing them make sense.

There is no wrong place to land

You might have lost faith entirely, and be quietly grieving that too.

You might have found it deepened, the thing that carried you, and feel almost guilty for the days you doubted.

Or you might live somewhere in the restless middle. Praying and not sure to whom. Lighting the candle out of habit, or love, or a hope you cannot name.

No one gets to tell you which of these is right. Not the person who kept their faith and cannot understand yours breaking. Not the person who lost theirs and cannot understand yours holding.

This is not a test you are passing or failing. It is the "why" that has no answer, asked by someone still standing in the middle of it.

The rosary stays in the drawer. Some days you almost reach for it.

You do not have to know yet whether you will.

More in Faith, meaning and signs, or browse the whole library.