Happy Grieving

Two things can be true: grief and joy in the same hour

The short answer

Grief and joy can be true at the same time, in the same hour, in the same breath. This is the bittersweet: a joyous moment tinged with missing, or a hard day that still holds something good. It is not confusion and it does not need to be resolved. Over time, you might stop trying to pick which feeling is the real one and let both be there.

The memory comes up on your phone, two years ago today, and you are smiling at it before you remember what "two years ago" now means.

Both land in the same second. The warmth of the picture. The weight of the date.

You wait for one of them to win. Neither does.

There's a phrase for this: two things can be true at once. Not in sequence, not one softening into the other. At the same time, in the same hour, sharing the same body.

The same hour, not the same story

We are taught grief and joy take turns. Bad day, good day. The dark stretch, then the coming through.

But it rarely runs so tidily.

You laugh at the dinner table and feel the missing in the same breath. The vacation is lovely and there is an empty seat at every view. You are proud of the new job and there is no one left to call first.

It can stop feeling like a paradox and start feeling like the weather. A joyous moment tinged with something underneath. A heavy morning that still has a good coffee in it.

The bittersweet is both, whole, at once, and it does not need to be solved.

Nothing to reconcile

The instinct is to pick. To decide whether this is a happy day or a sad one, as if the feeling has to file under a single heading.

It doesn't.

You can love the wedding and ache all the way through it. You can mean the laugh and mean the tears that come right after, and neither one cancels the other out. The wave and the calm can share the same sea.

Holding both isn't a mood you failed to manage. It is what it can feel like to carry someone you loved into a life that is still, stubbornly, good in places.

Some hours you will feel the grief more. Some the joy. Plenty of hours, both at full volume, and you standing in the middle of them, not choosing.

And if joy feels far away right now, that's okay too. It doesn't have to arrive on any schedule.

When people ask how you are

The hardest part is often the small talk. "How are you?" wants one answer, and you have two, and they are both honest.

Fine. And not. Happy today. And missing them today. You learn to give the version the moment can hold, and to keep the whole of it for the people who can take the whole of it.

The ones who get it don't flinch when you laugh with wet eyes. They don't ask you to pick.

Five years on, I still catch myself somewhere lovely, properly happy, and missing my dad in the same breath.

I let them both stay.

More in The first year, and after, or browse the whole library.